Dissolve sugar, salt, pepper, paprika, and dry mustard in olive oil.
Stir in vinegar. Peel and mince garlic and and add to dressing.
Get creative: based on the statistics of over 100,000 recipes, here are some other ingredients that are commonly used with the ingredients in this recipe that you might want to experiment by adding one or two of the following (amounts adjusted assuming you making 16 servings):
olive oil: 22%
olive oil: 6%